Braves Lose Both Catchers in 10 Days: Murphy's Eight-Week Timeline and Baldwin's Oblique

Both Atlanta Catchers Are On the Injured List. Eight Weeks For Murphy, Oblique For Baldwin.

The Atlanta Braves placed Sean Murphy on the 10-day injured list with a fractured left middle finger, retroactive to May 11, and manager Walt Weiss said Murphy could be out up to eight weeks. Murphy suffered the fracture Sunday on a swing by Dodgers second baseman Hyeseong Kim that connected with the glove. He had played in only four games this season after a delayed return from offseason hip surgery.

The harder hit landed eight days later. The Braves placed Drake Baldwin on the 10-day IL on May 19 with a strained left oblique. Baldwin was hitting .303 with 13 home runs, 38 RBIs, and a .932 OPS in 48 games. He was the most productive catcher in the National League over the first six weeks. The team promoted Chadwick Tromp from Triple-A Gwinnett and signed Sandy Leon to a big-league deal. Atlanta's Opening Day catching depth chart has now been shredded.

The Murphy Timeline

Eight weeks from May 11 puts Murphy on a return target in early July. Catcher hand and finger fractures historically run long. Will Smith of the Dodgers missed seven weeks with a similar fracture in 2024. Mitch Garver lost 10 weeks to a fractured finger in 2022. The grip and bat speed return slowly, and the throwing arm side dictates the timeline. Murphy's fracture is on his glove hand, which is the better outcome for arm strength but still wrecks the bat for a month-plus post-return.

The Braves had Murphy targeted for a 110-game workload after the hip recovery, splitting time with Baldwin and giving the offense two above-average catchers in the lineup most nights. That plan is now scrap paper. Even on the aggressive return path, Murphy is looking at 50 to 60 games the rest of the way.

Baldwin's Oblique and Why It Matters More

Oblique strains are tricky for catchers in particular. The rotational mechanics of throwing, framing, and swinging all run through the core. Baldwin's IL stint is 10 days minimum, but the historical norm for catcher obliques is three to five weeks of total absence. A 2024 Baseball Prospectus injury study put the average catcher oblique return at 26 days, with a 31% recurrence rate inside the same season.

Baldwin was the breakout. He had a 137 OPS+, was top three among NL catchers in barrel rate, and had become the everyday starter while Murphy worked back. Losing him for a month is the bigger fantasy and DFS event than the Murphy news, because Baldwin was actively producing top-12 catcher value.

The Sandy Leon and Chadwick Tromp Tandem

Sandy Leon last cleared a 60 OPS+ in 2019. He is a defensive specialist with career rate stats that read .195/.262/.291. Chadwick Tromp has 247 career MLB at-bats with a .230 average and is a Triple-A organizational depth piece. In any standard or two-catcher fantasy league, neither belongs on a roster.

The implication for the rest of the Braves offense is more interesting. Atlanta's run production was already trending below the 2023 peak, and the lineup now loses meaningful production from a spot that was hitting .303. The team has Matt Olson, Ronald Acuna Jr. (limited workload), Marcell Ozuna, and Austin Riley to carry the load, but the spots in the order behind them just got softer.

Betting and DFS Impact

The Braves opened as plus-110 NL East division favorites in late March. As of Thursday morning, that price has drifted to plus-150 on DraftKings, with the Phillies now favored at minus-130. The Murphy news was already priced in. The Baldwin news, which broke Tuesday, was not. Expect the division price on Atlanta to drift further if Leon and Tromp continue to start.

DFS exposure changes:

1. Braves team total: Drop a half-run from any pre-injury slate projection. The lineup is two everyday hitters short with Murphy and Baldwin both out and Acuna on a hard usage cap. 2. Opposing pitchers vs. Atlanta: Modest bump in strikeout props. Leon's career strikeout rate is 25.8%. Tromp's is 28.4%. Baldwin's was 22.1%. 3. Catcher streamers: Tromp is not a play. Leon is not a play. If you are forced to fill a fantasy two-catcher slot with the Braves' job, ride it for the position-eligibility week and then move on.

The deeper fantasy angle is the catcher market broadly. With Cal Raleigh on the IL (oblique), Baldwin out, Murphy out, William Contreras still working back from offseason knee surgery, and Adley Rutschman in a power slump, the top-12 catcher rankings have a real opening. Yainer Diaz, Bo Naylor, and even Carson Kelly become more interesting in this window.

What to Watch Next

The Braves play the Nationals tonight in Atlanta and the Marlins in Miami this weekend. The first catching usage data point is whether Tromp or Leon gets the Friday night start against rookie left-hander Cade Cavalli. Brian Snitker has historically preferred his veteran catcher against opposing rookies, which would put Leon behind the plate.

Three things on the calendar:

1. Murphy's six-week imaging update, expected the week of June 22, will dictate whether the eight-week timeline holds or slips to 10. 2. Baldwin's first dry swing report. Catchers with obliques typically miss two weeks before they can take full swings. Watch for an Atlanta beat report by June 2. 3. The July 31 trade deadline. If Atlanta is still in the race and Murphy is not back to full strength, the Braves become an obvious buyer at catcher. Industry names already floating include Tucker Barnhart and Reese McGuire.

Chad AI tracks every catcher prop and start-of-game probable inside the Stat Sniper app, with full Atlanta lineup modeling through the Murphy and Baldwin return windows.

If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, crisis counseling and referral services can be accessed by calling 1-800-GAMBLER.